1. Dorothy represents a quest for community. She personifies those who
are still young enough to hope and to act. Dorothy is Dorothy Everybody...even
you. On the other hand, hard times in life are symbolized by
2. Aunt Em and Uncle Henry: hard times in Kansas in 1896 had taken the
sparkle from their eyes and the color from their life. They lived in a
in a grey house in a grey land; and they were sober grey. They did not
smile.
Aunt Em and Uncle Henry are all the people hurt by the social institutions
of the USA; racism, class privilege, sexism, ageism and bureaucratic arrogance.
At one time or another, we are all Uncle Henry or Aunt Em.
3. Kansas and the farm on which Uncle Henry and Aunt Em lived represented
the economic conditions of the country after the depressions of 1873 and
1893. A great grey flat plain without trees, flowers, or water, it was
hard-baked by the pitiless sun.
Once again there are hard times; crime, unemployment, poverty, domestic
violence, increasingly inequality between rich and poor, black and white
in the USA as well as between the rich countries of Europe and North America
and the poor countries in the 3rd world.
4. Toto was the one bright spot in Dorothy's life. Toto represents the
clown/jokester in history who unmasks pretense and deception. Baum is Toto
and so is everyone who laughs at a Kings, Charlatans and Tyrants. Toto
can be anybody; even you as you use your imagination to poke a bit of fun
at the candidates for president in 1996.
5. The Cyclone represents the power of the people to overturn alienating
social conditions. It is comprised of the North, East, West and South winds
in the story. When people from Wyoming, California, Texas and New York
come together, they can better work for change and renewal.
In this version of the story, we will let the four winds represent workers
who lose jobs to 3rd world countries; folks who are angry about violence
and sex on television and in movie; retired people who are worried about
social security and cost of health care. You can add a fourth wind or even
make up your own list. That is what is nice about a metaphor...the rules
permit everyone to play.
6. The house in which Dorothy descended represents the government; it is
safe enough in good weather but doesn't give much protection in bad weather.
The four winds pick it up and set it down in the Land of Oz. We can agree,
I think, that the federal government still provides shaky shelter for those
who have to live with it every day.
7. Oz is Utopia. With bright colors, happy people and a brook which bubbled
nearby, Oz is the possibility of a good and decent society. But things
weren't always good in Oz...until the house crushed one of them, there
were two evil witches who oppressed the people.
Oz is, in the movie, Some Where Over the Rainbow. It is still there, somewhere.
Maybe we can find it in the 21st Century.
8. The Wicked Witch from the East represented finance capital which keep
the country on a gold standard with high interest rates while the Wicked
Witch from the West represented railroad barons who exploited the farmers
of the Midwest. The farmers had to pay high interest rates, high prices
for manufactured goods and high prices to ship their beef and grain to
Eastern markets by rail as a result of monopolies.
9. There were four regions of Oz in the original story. See Map. Dorothy
came down in the Land of the Munchkins. They once were full-sized people
but were made small by the working conditions imposed upon them by the
Wicked Witches. The Munchkins were very happy that Dorothy killed the Eastern
Witch and wanted her to stay and be their Queen but Dorothy wanted to go
home to Uncle Henry and Aunt Em.
10. Dorothy was helped by the good Witch from the North, Jocasta who symbolized
abstract good. She gave Dorothy the kiss of Goodness which protected her
from the many dangers on.
There were two good witches: Jocasta and Glinda. Baum may have had his
mother-in-law, Matilda Jocelyn Gage, in mind for the good Witch. She was
an early suffragette and worked with Susan B. Antony. In Greek mythology,
Jocasta was mother of Oedipus. I think we better leave that one to the
freudians among us. I have no idea who Glinda might have been but, if I
were to nominate one today, it would be Molly Ivins, the columnist from
the Great and Glorious State of Texas.
. 11. The Yellow Brick Road. The gold bricks of the road stood for the
gold bricks of the Eastern Bankers who insisted upon the gold standard,
itself a symbol of the tight money policy which was ruining farmers and
small businesses. You may have heard of the famous speech by Wm. Jennings
Bryan who said that America was being crucified on a Cross of Gold. The
road fell apart as one travelled on it and ended in the poppy field.
12. The Silver Slippers (not ruby) embodied the people's demand for bi-metal
money policy: populists wanted both the gold standard and the silver standard
to back up the currency.
In the book, whoever wore the silver slippers was safe when walking on
the Yellow Brick Road...that is why the Wicked Witch from the West demanded
Dorothy give them to her. She wanted control of money and monetary policy.
The populist politics of the time demanded low interest rates, good wages
and fair prices for farm products as against the high interest rates and
high prices of the 'great malefactors of wealth' who organized the monopolies
and cartels. They thought that silver would make money easier to borrow
since there was so much more silver than gold.
13. The Strawman was a takeoff on the farmers who didn't have enough brains
to vote for Wm Jennings Bryan. The Strawman embodies the quest for good
theory and good understanding. We all would be better off if we only had
a brain. You may recall that the Strawman was first seen hung on a cross
in the cornfield. Again there is that crucifixion theme. Y.P. Harburgh
wrote a lovely song about the Scarecrow...he would '...unravel every riddle
for any individle in trouble or in pain...' if he only had a brain.
In 1996, farmers may once again be showing signs of stupidity. The new
Farm Bill removes all the farm subsidies over the next seven years. Conservative
Senators they sent to Washington from the farm states drafted the Bill
and helped pass it.
14. The Tinman once had a heart; he had been in love with a girl but he
worked for the Wicked Witch from the East. The Witch, wicked lady she is,
made him work so fast that he cut off first an arm, then a leg, then split
himself down the middle with his ax. After each accident, a tinsmith repaired
him but after it was all over, the Tinman didn't have a heart. He wanted
a heart so he could, once again, love his sweetheart.
His is a search for the authentic sharing and giving of love. Christians
call this kind of love, compassion, caritas and agape. Each religion has
their own name.
Few of the candidates in the 1996 campaign have much of a heart. Indeed
hate, malice and loathing seem to fill most of the campaigns ads. Maybe
they will read this and join us in our effort to find a bit of compassion
in our own lives.
15. The Cowardly Lion was a putdown of Wm. Jennings Bryan who was too cowardly
to enter the race for President after being defeated the first time he
ran. Bryan raved and roared at small critters like Toto but he was too
cowardly to attack the big tycoons of industry and finance again after
being defeated in 1896. But in the book, the Lion drew courage from his
friends and protected them from the giant Kalidahs...two fearsome beasts
not used in the movie.
Baum went bankrupt in the 1893 depression; his assets were seized by the
Sheriff. He may have had the police in mind for one of these two great
beasts.
16. The Wizard of Oz symbolized alienated politics. Baum was making fun
of people who assign their power to politicians then go back to them, hat-in-hand
asking for help. The Wizard was the kind of politician who don't want to
see the people since he can't give them what they don't have in the first
place or what they already have. His real name was Oscar Z. Phadrig Isaac
Norman Hinkle Emmanuel Ambroise Diggs.
Folks in New Hampshire, Iowa and South Carolina complained that they never
saw the candidates...only their advertisements. They like Pat Buchanan
because he is out there shaking hands and talking to people. He also represents
a lot of the 1886 populist politics; a mix of fundamentalist religion,
protectionist policies and the concerns of small people...just like the
Munchkins. Mr. Buchanan serves excellently well for the Wizard of Oz in
1996; the question is, if he is elected, will he stay in touch with people??
17. Washington D.C. inspired the Emerald City concept. It was green because
green is the color of money and in Washington, money is the name of the
game. Washington represents any false solution to any social problem. It
takes more than money to solve problems; it takes heart, brains, courage
and community. In the book, our four heros/heroines find these on the journey
itself. The Tin Man weeps for the ants he crushed on the Yellow Brick Road;
the Strawman uses his brain several times to solve problems; the Cowardly
Lion saves the tiny group from the Kalidahs and Dorothy brings a sense
of community and sharing with her. That is the final moral of the story;
we find already have the capacity to solve our own problems...we don't
have to rely on politicians to save us.
18. The Flying Monkeys may have represented the newly freed slaves. Baum
lived in the aftermath of the Civil War. In the story, there was a Golden
Cap; the Monkeys were slaves to whomever had the Cap: it came with three
wishes. Dorothy took the Cap after she killed the Wicked Witch from the
West and used the third wish to get them to fly her and her three companions
back to the Emerald. Then the monkeys were free.
MGM was having labor troubles in the 30's so Samuel Goldwyn turned the
monkeys into villainous Russians. Goldwyn also ordered the song, Somewhere
Over the Rainbow to be cut from the movie; he thought it to radical; the
director and actors insisted he keep it. Wow, near thing, that!
19. The Golden Cap represents learning and understanding. Both can be used
to hurt people or to help them. What do you think? Would you use what you
know about workers, customers, or voters to deceive and swindle them? Naaah.
Do candidates in 1996 use what their pollsters tell them to deceive voters?
Naaah!
20. The Poppy field was used to represent anything that put people to sleep...that
immobilized them. Drugs, Monday Night Football, HBO, whatever turns people
into couch potatoes. Are you a couch potato or would you rather learn all
the days of your life so you can help Dorothy and her friends go over the
Rainbow and make a dream come true?
There is a lot more to the book that didn't make Hollywood; the Hammerheads
who were rooted in one spot and knocked down anyone who tried to go beyond
them; the China people who were crushed underfoot by vandals; the Octospider
which devoured all creatures it reached; the Wildcat who chased the Queen
of the Mice who rescued Dorothy and her friends from the Poppy field; the
trees that grabbed and caught at all who passed by them represented the
various branches of science used against the people. Then too, there were
two great ditches in the book; the depressions of 1873 and 1893. Lots of
good stuff left to make another movie.
The most important part of the book was destroyed by Goldwyn and his writers.
When you read the book, you see that the Strawman learns to think when
his friends have problems, the Tinman learns compassion when he finds he
has crushed ants on the yellow brick road and the Lion finds enough courage
to save the foursome and Toto from the giant Kalidahs which pursue them.
We can't get love, brains or courage from a bottle or from a Wizard; we
can only get them by doing them.
This story ends when Dorothy demands that the Wizard give the people what
he promised them. So he gave the Strawman a 'bran'-new brain complete with
pins and needles so he would be sharp. He gave the Tinman a heart shaped
watch which was guaranteed to go on ticking. He pulled out a bottle of
green liquid and gave the Lion a big drink...as the Wizard said, lots of
people get courage from a bottle. (There are a lot of horrible puns in
the book). But he could not help Dorothy get back home...later the Good
Witch from the South told her that she always had the power to go home;
she was wearing the silver slippers. Dorothy did go home. She found Uncle
Henry and Aunt Em smiling; there was pink in their cheeks and red in their
lips. The house was newly painted; the grass, fields and trees were green
and once again the promise of Spring was fulfilled. The Tinman and the
Strawman stayed to help govern the other lands of Oz.
However, the story never really ends. History begins anew with each generation;
it begins anew when you too exhibit brains, courage, compassion and community.
In the USA, in the Eastern Communist Bloc, in the poor barrios and small
farms in Latin America, in the wonderful savannas and shambas of Africa,
in the lovely cities and quiet villages of Asia, the same four virtues,
wrapped in policies of social justice, move us toward our full humanity.
In as much as each of those who read or hear this story cannot but move
toward the fullness of your morality, on behalf of the Wizard of Oz and
as the self-proclaimed Official Populist Historian of the Great and Mighty
Land of Oz, I hereby grant each of you the right and obligation to work
all the days of your life for social justice. You can begin by working
toward better gender relations; toward the end of racism; toward economic
dignity and democracy and toward a sense of community that embraces all
creatures bright and beautiful on this good earth. When you do this, you
are living the best of your religion. What better journey can you take
through the pages of your life????
|
Cross of Gold Then we heard these glacial boulders across the prairie rolled; 'The people have a right to make their own mistakes... You shall not crucify mankind upon a cross of Gold.' Election night at midnight: Boy Bryan's defeat. Defeat of silver, Defeat of the wheat. Victory of letterfiles and plutocrats with greasy smiles with dollar signs upon their coats diamond watchchains on their vests and spats on their feet. [...more in the original] Vachel Lindsay |
About L. Frank Baum
1. Baum was born in upper New York State. He took courses at Columbia University;
some in journalism.
2. Baum married Maud Gage, daughter of Matilda Jocelyn Gage, well known
Suffragette.
3. After trying several jobs, Baum took his family to South Dakota where
he owned and edited a paper in S. Dakota. He depended upon small business
and small farmers for survival ... the railroads finance capital put many
out of business ... Baum went bankrupt; sheriff's officers seized his assets...
4. Baum moved to Chicago just in time for the Haymarket Massacre which
he covered as a reporter.
5. Baum met Wm. Jennings Bryan and was actively reporting the campaign
of 1896 ... on the side of the populist movement.
6. Baum was a born right after the Civil War and grew up in the racist
climate of the post-war period... and reported on the election of 1877
that gave the election to Hayes and sold out the interests of Afro-Americans
to southern gentlemen...
I have absolutely no outside evidence for my interpretation that the Flying
Monkeys may have symbolized former slaves, however in the book, the flying
monkeys were under the control of whomever had possession of the Golden
Cap... (Dorothy stole it and used it to get to the Emerald City the second
time round... little juvenile delinquent, she]. The WWWest had the Cap;
it gave three wishes to which the monkeys had to respond... by the time
Dorothy got it, there was one wish left... she used it and the monkeys
were freed ... they were very happy to be rid of their captivity by the
golden cap... and its owner.
7. Baum's stories became increasingly depoliticized [and considerably less
interesting as he prospered]. I think it fair to say that he lost the critical
edge when he joined the establishment.
8. There were a lot of events in the book which I've not mentioned... all
of which have a very critical edge:
A. The Hammerheads ... they were rooted on the side of
a hill and used their heads to knock down anybody who wanted to get past
them... I could have used this episode to talk about Buchanan and some
of his more strident supporters but, as most people don't know about this
part of Baum, I didn't include it.
B. The Chinamen ... they were very small people who lived behind a wall
but large white people just stepped over it and crushed the china men and
women underfoot... Baum lived through the Great Land Grab scheme of railroad
Barons and knew of the exploitation and death rates of chinese workers
on the railroads ... that push came after the Civil War...
C. The Octospider... may have been a steal from a popular novel about big
business... or maybe the other way 'round... any rate, Baum had the Octospider
gobbling up every small defenseless critter which got close... this was
the age of great cartels and oligarchies... Both Wm J. Bryan and Teddy
Roosevelt make their depredations visible in the political arena ... as
does Buchanan today.
There were a lot of other stories... I used some of them
in an old 1972 article published, I think, in Soc Enquiry entitled, The
Yellow Brick Road to Success in American Sociology... lots of fun, that.
9. Finally, if one wants to take a postmodern view of literature, one could
argue that every exegesis of every text is original ... not even the same
author gives the same meaning to the same story at subsequent readings
...
That true, my 'reading' of the Wizard of Oz stands on its own merits. If
you hesitate to attribute these interpretations to Baum, you can most certainly
attribute them to me.... at least until I get rich from all royalties and
fees from my interpretation and change my mind.