The Future of U.S. Capitalism: Social Problems in 21st cent.
It was my particular pleasure to give the following mini-lecture to
the students of Diane Schaefer at the University of Indiana this past
week. Diane is a grad student at UI and had organized a visit for me
which included dinner with her and three other grad students at UI.
I had not been at UI before and was most pleased to visit. UI is the
home of three people who have forever altered the way we think about
life and the world. James Watson, who with Francis Crick developed
our understanding about DNA, was on the faculty there. Ed Sutherland
forever changed criminology; before Sutherland, street crime was the
only focus. Since Sutherland, criminology has expanded to include
white collar crime, corporate crime and political crime...crimes of
the middle and upper class which were excluded most conveniently
from both law, policing and research. Then too, Kinsey did his basic
work there which has forever changed our hitherto religously informed
ideas about sex and sexuality.
So it was a pleasure to stroll around campus with Diane and, later,
Hal Pepinsky. Pepinsky, by the way, along with Richard Quinney, is
working to convert criminology from its mindless peace-keeping orient-
ation to the much more affirmative/progressive/humanist peace-making.
So 'twas a great honor for me to lecture on the same campus as these
most remarkable scholars....and petty revenge for the beating UI gave
UMichigan a few weeks ago in football.
Efforts to predict the future of any human activity is risky
business indeed...since most human processes are non-linear; often
taking qualitative leaps, twists, reverses and skips. Economics is
often called the dismal science...non-the-less there is enough order
and continuity in human affairs to make some rough guesses about what
may happen. In the new sciences of chaos/complexity, there are two
new attributes of prediction which I have included in the analysis
below: first one sets four to eight outcome states rather than trying
to favor one and only one as does modernist scientific sensibility.
Secondly, one looks at non-linear interactions between key variables
rather than directional causality. The framing concept for so doing
is the ALGORITHM. An algorithm is simply a set of directions which,
loosely, push a system to one region of time/space rather than another.
In sociology, several key factors will interact and push the USA toward
any one of several futures which I will try to anticipate below.
- The Sociological Imagination. In the lecture, I tried to make the
point that the way the USA fits itself into the globalizing
political economy will shape/pre-shape the degree to which each
student in the class today will work, worship, play, learn and
earn. Global structures now shape personal destinies.
But destiny is not pre-determined as it is in both the totalizing
theory of modernist science and the monopolizing pre-theory of
pre-scientific times. Indeed, with wit and wisdom, with good
theory and good politics, human beings working together using
human judgment can feed back into the political economy to
make it do its proper job...serve human ends rather than corporate
purpose.
- I began by making the case that capitalism was/is a very, very
dynamic system in several respects:
- The center of capitalism moves and moves at an ever-increasing
pace. Capitalism begins as commodity capitalism in the 13th
c. as crusading armies from northern Europe converged on Venice
to depart for Palestine. Great wealth accumulated for the
merchants of Venice. Both feudalism, slavery and tribal
communalism were thus forever doomed.
Commodity capitalism moved to Brussels in the 15th c.
Comodity capitalism moved to London in the 17th c.
Commodity capitalism transformed cottage industry into
factory industry when steam power was linked to production
of goods at Huddersfield, England in the 18th c.
Industrial capitalism moved to New England and the USA in the
19th century...and expanded to form the now dominant sector
of capitalism: finance capitalism.
Commercial/Industrial/finance capitalism shifted its center to
Japan in the 20th century. In 1985, ten out of ten of the
biggest banks were based in the USA; in 1996, 10 of 10 biggest
banks are in Japan.
- The Advantages of Capitalism. I always begin lecture series on the
positivities of capitalism; most marxists/political economists do
not...and thus alienate students from the lecture. So do be sure
to make the following points when you lecture/write on economic
sociology:
- Capitalism is the most productive economic system heretofore
developed.
- Capitalism is the most innovative system so far developed.
- Capitalism is the most flexible system yet created by humans.
- Capitalism requires an ever-improving knowledge system.
- Capitalism tends to destroy ancient forms of privilege, power
and social status...not excluding race, gender, religion and
ethnic preferences.
- Capitalism requires social peace; the movement of jobs, capital,
profit, goods, and employees in a globalized economy means the
end of predatory warfare in its military modality...many would
argue and I not deny that that peace is the false peace of
economic hegemony non-the-less it is a sea-change from previous
use of force to capture markets, access raw materials and
exploit labor in 3rd world colonies....future wars will begin
as ethnic cleansing and end as economic suicide.
- The Structure of the Global Political Economy in 1996. It is very
important to a structural analysis of social problems to locate
the major driving forces of human prosperity and human despair.
For most of human history, micro-social processes in micro-ecosytem
niches shaped infant mortality rates, longevity, quality of life
suicide, murder, warfare, family dis-ordre and social collapse.
Now what happens in Toyko and Hong Kong affects crime rates in
Omaha and Orlando. It is very important your students begin to
understand the social sources of private problems...as Mills said.
- There are some 1000 Transnational corporations which run the
global political economy. some 300 are based in the USA.
- The global political economy is heavily stratified and becoming
weekly, more sharply inequal in terms of wealth, power and
status.
- There are some 160 nation-states. At the top are the Big
Seven: England, France, Germany, Italy, Canada and Japan.
The USA dominates the Big Seven; the rich industrial nations
and the global political economy....today.
- There are some six NIC's...newly industrialize countries
which are attracting capital, jobs, factories and skilled
workers from the developed countries.
- There are some 20 old capitalist/colonial powers which still
provide their citizens with quite a good life style...mostly
socialist democracies which provide decent programs in
health care, education, housing, recreation and retirement
for their citizens...the USA ranks at the low end of all
such countries in terms of social justice...ours is a cheap-
jack, mean-sprited welfare systems in which the poor are
both blamed and demonized for the poverty which is more a
structural feature than a functional requirement as Davis
and Moore claim in their infamous essay.
- Ther are some 15 socialist states just hanging on. They
haven't learned the great lesson of the 20th century;
bureaucratic/totalitarian socialism won't work; it lacks
the advantages of capitalism above.
- The rest of the world is said to be the 3rd world of
development....more about which later.
- Bloc Formation: In the first 25 years of the 21st c., a most
interesting structural feature of the Global Political economy
will be Bloc Formation...the nation-state becomes ever-more
irrelevant/powerless in the algorithms of power and wealth.
I count some 10-12 blocs emerging, the most advanced is of
course, the European Union...but the North American bloc is
well along; NAFTA will be a powerful actor in 21st century.
The South American Cone will likely from a bloc as will
Sub-Saharan Africa...Japan will finally get her Co-prosperity
Sphere which may include NZ and Oz. The Islamic countries may
form two or even three economic blocs. Since the Arab states
control most of the oil reserves, it will be a force to reckon.
All by itself, China is a bloc; when Hong Kong joins it next
year, the structure of the global economy will make undergo
great change. The same is true of India; it has cheap labor,
a well trained/skilled professional class, fair transport,
fair communications and a new global-oriented leadership.
So, just as nations displaced counties and townships, blocs
will replace nations as a major social form in human affairs.
more in another lecture.
Israel deserves special mention...it may join the Sub-sahran
Bloc and, with South Africa, make it a player on the world
stage...when I visited Israel three years ago, it was gearing
itself to fit into a global political economy...there are 3
places in Israel where new industries are fostered and then
cut loose; I visited Kafir Vradim in n. Israel...it was a
lesson in how to manufacture business for the global system.
- Key variables in American Capitalism. The following variables
are important parts of the North American Algorithm...the set of
instructions which politicians, scholars, and CEO's will have to
'read out' in order to plan and to program US policy.
- Consumer Demand. One of the features of capitalism is that
while it is a magnificent system of production, it is a lousy
system of distribution...improvement in productivity tends to
dis-employ workers; profit tends to separate every body from
the means of distribution...capitalism is the only economic
system which does so; in all other economic systems, the
whole point of production was distribution...not so capitalism.
So...how to renew demand...there are several solutions.
- Parallel economic systems. There are a half-dozen
economic systems in the USA which supplement/redeem
the market system: the family is the most important
parallel system...it re-distributes huge amounts of
goods and services...especially at Christmas time.
(worked that in nicely, didn't I??).
Crime is a very, very important parallel system; it
provides a lot of jobs for the underclass, stimulates
the legitimate economy, creates ever-more service
sectors (private security is larger than public policing).
The welfare state continues to re-distribute huge sums
mostly upward but still enough downward to buy a thin
social peace.
The church continues to be the place of last resort for
the homeless, tempest-tost, poor huddled masses discarded
by market, family, state and too proud to do crime...most
of the time.
Without these parallel economic systems, 'twould be a
terrible time for hunreds of millions in North America.
- The future of the USA capitalism depends in great part upon
its military. It is the only Super-Power in the world. Many
old and new capitalist countries depend upon it for the
social peace both national and trans-national needed for
local capitalists to survive and thrive.
Bill Clinton is explicit about this...along with Richard
Nixon, he realized more than most presidents that the future
of American capitalism depends upon the US retaining its
position at the top of the global order.
- One should watch France and the EU; France engineered the
end of the link between the dollar and the gold standard in
the 70's; it is trying to displace the US dollar which is now
the universal currency...with the euro-bill...this is one key
- There are three or four fiscal tools which shape life variables
in the global system. The USA controls the World Bank, the
OEDC and AID and the International Monetary Fund...these
together are used to force 3rd world countries to reduce debt
at home and to US, German, British and Japanese banks. And
bring home a lot of wealth/profits/food to the developed
countries...without control of these tools, the US is forced
to rely on the CIA and direct military intervention...very
costly in terms of dollars and in terms of political legit-
imacy...that is the lesson of Vietnam.
- US properity hinges upon the creation of new consumer goods.
There have been 4 or 5 great depressions since 1800; new
inventions have worked to renew demand and economic growth.
The automobile, railroads, television, radio, cinema,
computers and now the Internet continue to stimulate demand.
- Political legitimacy at home is crucial. As the underclass
grows; as white male workers are marginalized; as the middle
class continues to bear more and more of the tax burden...to
the delight of the wealthy; as political corruption and
bureaucratic ineptitudes continue to dis-enchant people from
the nation-state, legitimacy becomes a serious problem.
There are solutions. Social justice is the best solution but
it is costly to the wealthy. Racism, religiousity, the false
masculinities of sports and violence, demonization of the young,
gender bashing and national chauvinism still work to shape
both street politics, public policy and private relationships.
These are, however, short-term and self-defeating solutions
which may postpone civil strife but at the expense of social
and economic health of the country.
Again, social justice is the best long-term solution...not
criminal justice nor incivility toward minorities. Social
justice...
- Five futures for America. Modern science requires one predict one
and only one outcome state. Postmodern science permits/requires
a plurality of parallel and contrary outcomes. I predict all the
following in varying unpredictable combination:
- The Soylent Green Solution...well protected residences and
working space for the affluent and their clients; a reactive
police presence for the growing underclass left to parasitize
upon itself.
- The English Model: genteel impoverishment...as was the case
with Greece, Rome and other imperial countries before it, the
USA may follow the English example; relinquish power and status
to any one of the NICs and grow old with some grace.
- The Serbian Model...internal/incestuous warfare in which one
ethnic enclave claims superiority and tries to solve its
social problems on the backs of other ethnic enclaves.
- The Theological State...Islam and Israel are both attempting
to impose an religousity and exclusivity upon those within
the borders of given nation-states. In Islamic states, Islamic
law provides very important solutions to poverty, housing,
health care and social peace...gender inequality remains but
class inequality is greatly minimized...Islam is most appealing
to the poor in such countries...as is religious fundamentalism
among the poor in the USA, the former Soviet Union and in Latin
America.
Liberation theologies may work to humanize/expand the shape of
Universal Being but just now, things look like more religious
conflict.
- Democratic Socialism. With the collapse of bureaucratic/repres-
sive socialism, other forms of socialism now seem more likely.
The Mondragon co=ops in northern Spain; Kerala State in India;
the communist cities of Italy; newly re-organizing nations in
Central Europe as well as the possibility of great improvement
in Cuba and perchance China hold out promise for a better way
to do social justice on a global scale.
I ended the lecture by telling the students that they now sit
on the edge of history and have a good seat with which to watch and
work for the kind of society they want...that sociology gives them the
concepts with which to understand the factors which shape their lives
and the models with which to re-shape them. I told them that others
at the University of Indiana had greatly influenced the world and that
their final field assignment was to do the same in their own life-time
...and that is your final assignment from this series of mini-lectures
as well.
Go in peace, TR